On paper, "The Girl Who Waited" was brilliant. Karen Gillan? A revelation. So why did I take a 45-minute walk around the neighborhood, grinding my teeth, trying to figure out how I felt about the episode?
Thanks to Huw at thirteenfaces.com for linking me to Emily Asher-Perrin's essay at tor.com on the relationship of the Doctor, and Doctor Who, to children. It was the whack on the side of the head that helped me understand my reaction.
Tags2MTL updates appreciation BBC America casting Christmas specials Clara classic series comics companions continuity conventions culture Doctor Who abroad DWO WhoCast Eleventh Doctor fandom Gallifrey One guest appearance guest commentary Hurricane Who interview Matt Smith new series online pontification regeneration review romance in the TARDIS Rose Tyler Russell T. Davies Series 1 Series 5 Series 6 Series 7 Series 8 Steven Moffat Tenth Doctor Throwback Toby Hadoke Tony Lee Torchwood Torchwood: Miracle Day TV biz Twelfth Doctor U.K. guest reviews